Pregnancy After Infertility Support
You're finally pregnant. So why don't you feel the way you thought you would?
Dancing Bee Counseling provides specialized support for pregnancy after infertility (PAI). After months or years of trying, treatments, and heartbreak, you expected pregnancy to feel like pure joy. Instead, you might feel anxiety, guilt, or strangely disconnected. You're not broken. You're experiencing the complex aftermath of infertility trauma, and you deserve support that understands this unique experience.
Why Pregnancy After Infertility Is Different
Pregnancy after infertility isn't the same as pregnancy that comes easily. You've been through something most pregnant people never experienced: the crushing disappointment of negative tests, the invasive medical procedures, the months or years of hoping and losing hope. Your nervous system learned to protect you from expecting good outcomes. That protection doesn't just switch off because you're finally pregnant.
You might be waiting for something to go wrong, unable to believe this is really happening. You might feel disconnected from the pregnancy, afraid to let yourself feel attached. You might watch other pregnant people glowing and excited and wonder what's wrong with you that you can't feel that way.
Nothing is wrong with you. What you're experiencing is a normal response to the trauma of infertility. Your heart learned to protect itself, and now it needs help learning that it's safe to hope again.
I provide therapy that understands this unique position: you're pregnant, which is what you wanted, but the anxiety, grief, and complex emotions that came with infertility don't disappear just because the test finally came back positive.
The Paradox of Getting What You Wanted
You fought so hard for this. You went through treatments, spent money, endured procedures, and put your life on hold. This pregnancy represents everything you've been working toward. So why doesn't it feel like you expected?
The truth is, pregnancy after infertility often brings a complicated mix of joy and fear, gratitude and guilt, excitement and anxiety. You can be thrilled to be pregnant and also terrified that something will go wrong. You can feel grateful and also resentful about how hard you had to work for this. Both things can be true at once.
Common Challenges in Pregnancy After Infertility
These experiences are normal. You're not alone in feeling this way.
Constant Anxiety
Waiting for something to go wrong. Checking for bleeding. Unable to relax into the pregnancy. Every twinge sending you into panic mode.
Emotional Numbness
Feeling disconnected from the pregnancy. Unable to feel the joy you expected. Protecting yourself from getting too attached.
Survivor's Guilt
Guilt about friends still struggling. Feeling wrong for having what others desperately want. Minimizing your pregnancy to spare their feelings.
Identity Confusion
Not feeling like you fit with "normal" pregnant people who didn't struggle. Not fitting in the infertility community anymore either. Caught between worlds.
Avoiding Bonding
Not buying baby things. Not choosing names. Not letting yourself imagine the future. Keeping emotional distance as self-protection.
Milestone Anxiety
Holding your breath until the heartbeat, then the 12-week mark, then the anatomy scan. Relief that lasts only until the next milestone arrives.
Grief That Lingers
Still mourning the losses, the failed cycles, the time that infertility took from you. Grief doesn't end just because pregnancy begins.
Medicalized Pregnancy
Constant monitoring that feels both reassuring and anxiety-provoking. More ultrasounds, more appointments, more opportunities to worry.
"Should Be Happy"
Pressure to feel grateful every moment. Guilt when you complain about pregnancy symptoms. Feeling like you're not allowed to struggle.
Anxiety at Every Milestone
Many people expect anxiety to end after certain points. Often, it just shifts to the next milestone.
"Is It Real?"
Disbelief. Testing again and again. Fear that it's another chemical pregnancy. Inability to let yourself believe it's actually happening this time.
"Will It Last?"
Relief that there's a heartbeat, followed almost immediately by fear that it could stop. Counting down to the next ultrasound for reassurance.
"Just Get to 12 Weeks"
Holding your breath through early pregnancy. Every day feels like a victory but also a countdown. Afraid to tell people before you're "safe."
"What If Something's Wrong?"
New fears about development, chromosomes, organs. Waiting for results feels unbearable. Relief followed by new things to worry about.
"But What About..."
Even after viability, new fears emerge: preterm labor, complications, stillbirth. The anxiety doesn't disappear; it evolves. Some find it continues into parenthood.
Survivor's Guilt in Pregnancy After Infertility
You know what it feels like to watch pregnancy announcements while you're struggling. You know the sting of baby showers, the pain of being left behind as friends moved on to parenthood. Now you're on the other side, and it can feel deeply uncomfortable.
Survivor's guilt is common in pregnancy after infertility. You may feel like you don't deserve to be happy while others are still suffering, like your joy is a betrayal of your friends still in the trenches.
Minimizing your pregnancy when talking to friends who are still trying
Not sharing news or ultrasound photos out of fear of hurting others
Feeling guilty when you complain about pregnancy symptoms
Hiding your joy because it feels inappropriate given others' pain
Identity and Belonging After Infertility
Pregnancy after infertility can leave you feeling like you don't fit anywhere.
"Graduating" from the RE
Leaving your reproductive endocrinologist's office for the last time can feel bittersweet. Relief at moving forward, but loss of the close monitoring that felt like a safety net. Who takes care of you now?
Leaving the Infertility Community
The infertility community understood you. Now you're not sure if you still belong, or if your presence is painful for those still struggling. Do you stay? Do you go? Where do you fit?
Not Fitting with "Normal" Pregnancy
Regular pregnancy groups can feel alienating. People complaining about how easy it was to get pregnant. Excitement that feels foreign. You don't share their experience, and they don't understand yours.
Identity Beyond Infertility
"The infertile one" was part of who you were. Who are you now? The struggle defined so much of your life. Pregnancy success can feel disorienting, even while being what you wanted most.
Pregnancy After Infertility Counseling
I provide therapy that understands the unique emotional landscape of PAI.
Anxiety Management
Strategies for managing the constant worry. Tools for surviving between appointments. Learning to be present instead of always waiting for disaster.
Processing Infertility Grief
The grief doesn't end with pregnancy. Space to mourn what infertility took from you, even while celebrating what you have now.
Survivor's Guilt Work
Exploring the guilt you feel about friends still struggling. Finding ways to honor your empathy without sacrificing your own joy.
Bonding Support
Helping you connect with this pregnancy and baby despite fear. Gently lowering the protective walls that infertility built.
Relationship Focus
How PAI affects your partnership. When you and your partner are processing differently. Reconnecting after the stress of treatment.
Preparing for Parenthood
When anxiety about pregnancy extends to fears about parenting. Processing how infertility might affect your identity as a parent.
Who Benefits from PAI Support
You're pregnant after infertility but can't stop worrying about what might go wrong
You don't feel as happy as you expected and wonder what's wrong with you
You feel guilty about your pregnancy while friends are still struggling
You're afraid to buy baby things or let yourself believe this is really happening
You're pregnant after IVF and carrying trauma from treatment
You don't know where you fit now that you're no longer trying to conceive
You miss the monitoring from your RE and feel anxious with regular OB care
You're still grieving the time and experiences infertility took from you
Questions About Pregnancy After Infertility
Why am I not happy now that I'm finally pregnant?
Many people who become pregnant after infertility don't feel the joy they expected. After months or years of hoping, you might feel numb, anxious, or even disconnected from the pregnancy. This is completely normal. Infertility taught you that positive tests can end in loss, that bodies can betray you, and that hope can lead to devastation. Your nervous system learned to protect you from disappointment. It can't just switch off that protection because you finally got pregnant. You may also be experiencing survivor's guilt about friends still struggling, grief for the time infertility took from you, or simply emotional exhaustion. Not feeling immediate joy doesn't mean you don't want this baby or won't be a good parent.
When does pregnancy after infertility anxiety go away?
For many people, the anxiety doesn't fully disappear; it shifts. You might feel intense anxiety until the first ultrasound, then anxiety until the heartbeat, then until the second trimester, then until viability. Each milestone brings brief relief followed by new fears. Some people find the anxiety lessens significantly after certain points; others carry it throughout pregnancy and even into parenthood. This doesn't mean you're broken or that therapy can't help. What therapy does is give you tools to manage the anxiety so it doesn't consume your pregnancy, help you be present for moments of joy when they come, and process the trauma that infertility left behind. The goal isn't to eliminate all anxiety but to keep it from stealing this experience from you.
Is it normal to feel guilty about being pregnant after infertility?
Survivor's guilt is extremely common in pregnancy after infertility. You know what it feels like to see pregnancy announcements while struggling. You know the pain of watching others get what you desperately want. Now you're on the other side, and it can feel uncomfortable, even wrong, to have what your friends are still fighting for. You might minimize your pregnancy, avoid sharing news, or feel like you don't deserve happiness because others are still suffering. This guilt is a sign of your empathy and your connection to the infertility community, but it can also prevent you from experiencing this pregnancy fully. Therapy can help you hold space for both your joy and your compassion without letting guilt diminish what you've been through to get here.
How do I bond with my baby during pregnancy after infertility?
Bonding can feel difficult when anxiety keeps you from fully believing the pregnancy is real or will result in a baby. You might avoid buying things, choosing names, or letting yourself imagine the future because it feels too risky. This self-protection makes sense given what you've been through, but it can leave you feeling disconnected. Bonding isn't a light switch; it develops over time and can happen even alongside anxiety. Some strategies include: talking to your belly even when it feels silly, journaling to your baby, allowing small moments of hope without requiring yourself to feel joy all the time, and working with a therapist on gradually lowering your protective walls. Many parents who struggled to bond during pregnancy find that connection comes after birth.
Should I stay in infertility support groups while pregnant?
This is a personal decision with no right answer. Some people feel they need to leave infertility spaces out of respect for those still struggling, or because their presence feels painful now. Others want to stay connected to the community that supported them. Consider: Does being in the group help or hurt your anxiety? Are you able to be sensitive about how you share? Does the group have guidelines about pregnant members? Some groups have separate spaces for those who are pregnant after infertility, which can be ideal because everyone understands both the struggle and the unique challenges of PAI. A therapist can help you navigate this transition and find the right balance of connection and boundaries.
Abby Lemke, MS, LPC-IT
Pregnancy After Infertility Specialist
I understand that pregnancy after infertility comes with complex emotions that people who conceived easily can't relate to. The anxiety that doesn't let you enjoy ultrasounds. The guilt when you see friends still struggling. The disconnection from your own pregnancy because letting yourself believe feels too dangerous.
As a member of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine with specialized training in fertility mental health, I know both the infertility journey and the unique challenges of what comes after. I won't tell you to "just be happy" or that you should be grateful every moment. I'll help you process what infertility took from you while supporting you through this pregnancy you worked so hard to achieve.
You deserve to be present for this experience, not just surviving it. I'm here to help.
More About AbbyPregnancy After Infertility Support in Madison, Wisconsin
๐ Dancing Bee Counseling
Office Address
101 E Main St, Suite 4
Waunakee, WI 53597
Phone
608-967-6105Serving Dane County and Beyond
You Deserve to Be Present for This
After everything you've been through, you deserve support that helps you experience this pregnancy, not just survive it.
In-person in Waunakee ยท Telehealth throughout Wisconsin